What are yours?

For me, the best was Deadpool
Worst: batman vs superman. I was so disappointed

Best: Wonder Woman
Worst: Fantastic Four (2008? When was the last reboot for it?)

Deadpool was great, but for me, the best comic book movie, still remains to be The Avengers, loved the first one, and it was great to see all those characters in the same movie at the same time. As for worst, where does one start? X-Men Origins: Wolverine, Catwoman, Elektra, and the newest Fantastic Four movie all absoluely sucked balls.

Best: Deadpool. I loved the meta nature of the film.


Worst: Eric Bana as The Hulk. There was nothing but talking and the times Banner turned into The Hulk was utterly wasted in most instances. Jennifer Connely was a waste of space.

Best is still The Dark Knight to me. That film had my attention from start to finish. Deadpool and Wonder Woman is still up there tho

Worst: Batman and Robin & Fantastic Four(newer). One is bad in the funny way, the other is bad in the boring way.

Does Logan count? Even my wife was pretty entertained by it.

Worst is much harder to nail down since there are so many.

If I'm keeping this wife-related, we were both really REALLY disappointed by the third Nolan Batman movie.

Sept 29, 2017 13:23:03 GMT 🤯 said:

Does Logan count? Even my wife was pretty entertained by it.

Worst is much harder to nail down since there are so many.

If I'm keeping this wife-related, we were both really REALLY disappointed by the third Nolan Batman movie.

Of course Logan counts, afterall it features the coolest Canadian mutant ever*


*I mean sure, he's like the only one, but still.

My favourite is either Dr. Strange or the first Thor film. Thor was my favourite Marvel movie until I saw Dr. Strange in 3D. By far the best use of 3D I've ever seen, to the point where I can't imagine what it would be like without it.

As for the worst. Well, I don't like most of the pre-Nolan Batman films, but they aren't actively bad. They are generally adequate brainless blockbuster films. The only bad comic movie that comes to mind is one of the Hulk films, but I don't remember which one. Might be The Incredible Hulk from...2008? Is that the one with Eric Bana?

Nope, the 2008 one was with Edward Norton. It was mostly forgettable unlike the awful one from 03.

Best :
The Dark Knight
The Winter Soldier
Logan

Worse :
Wolverine Origins
The Wolverine
Fantastic Four, the most recent.

Best is the Dark Knight.

Worst is Catwoman.

I feel lucky as most of the worst are ones I never bothered to see.

Sept 29, 2017 20:51:09 GMT Ness said:

Nope, the 2008 one was with Edward Norton. It was mostly forgettable unlike the awful one from 03.

This raises a question in my mind...  What's truly worse: to be memorably bad, or to be totally forgettable?

The Dark Knight is still the greatest comic movie of all time.

I'm going to say The Spirit is the worst adaptation. Just god awful.

My favorites are definitely Logan, Dredd, Winter Soldier, and The Dark Knight.


The worst is Batman and Robin and Green Lantern.

Best:

Batman Begins
Logan
Spider-Man 2
Captain America: Winter Soldier
Captain America: Civil War

Worst: (this is low hanging fruit btw)

Captain America (1979)
Captain America (1990)
Spider-Man (1978)
Howard The Duck
Batman and Robin

Just watched Deadpool last night with the wife.

I'm not sure if we liked it or Logan more, but it's up there in the "best" group.

I think I'm the only person who didn't love Logan. I liked it for sure, but I didn't come away from it wanting to ever rewatch unlike the other films that people put in the best column.