Way to many healthy cereals on this list.

The sweets are gonna be top heavy. Trust me.

Wheaties was my pick. Probably the only healthy-ish cereal we grew up eating. My dad loved watching sports and I grew up watching it too, so we loved seeing some of our favorites on the box. Not that that was the only reason, i really enjoy it.

Oct 24, 2017 23:59:59 GMT SM said:

Way to many healthy cereals on this list.

Don't besmirch the tastiness of Two Scoops Raisin Bran!

I'm also still not over Cinnamon Life ranking so low.

>:-(

17th Place



Life
11 Pts.
2 Lists
1 #1 Spot

16th Place



Golden Crisp
12 Pts.
3 Lists

15th Place



Honeycomb
14 Pts.
3 Lists

14th Place



Cocoa Pebbles
18 Pts.
4 Lists
1 #1 Spot

Oct 26, 2017 3:58:08 GMT jTjohncenaGOAT said:

My only fault with Raisin Bran is that it just has too many raisins. They advertise two scoops in every box but ya know.. a half scoop would be just fine for me.

Less? I use to add raisins to that. Because you get a bite without raisins it was awful.

Oct 26, 2017 10:57:35 GMT jTjohncenaGOAT said:

Oct 26, 2017 4:27:43 GMT X-zero said:

Less? I use to add raisins to that. Because you get a bite without raisins it was awful.

im not that big on raisins. Just a few here and there is fine.

But there is non-Two Scoop Raisin Bran. Why would you buy Two Scoop if you didn't like raisins!? Does this mean regular ass Raisin Bran might be making a higher appearance on this thing?

If I was pissed about Cinnamon Life's criminally low ranking, I'm fucking devastated by Life not even cracking the Top 10. So fucked up.

So fucked up.

Raisin Bran... Aka Lucky Charms for adults. Only one person specified two scoops so I counted them together. To me two scoops is like qtips or kleenex. It defines the brand.

Oct 26, 2017 16:56:31 GMT @ness said:

Raisin Bran... Aka Lucky Charms for adults. Only one person specified two scoops so I counted them together. To me two scoops is like qtips or kleenex. It defines the brand.

There are two version of Raisin Bran? I thought all boxes said with two scoops.



So far
6. Raisin Bran - 18th
7. Honey Smacks - 43rd
8. Golden Crisp - 16th
9. Cocoa Pebbles -14th

13th Place



Apple Jacks
21 Pts.
5 Lists

12th Place



Cap'n Crunch (Peanut Butter Crunch)
22 Pts.
3 Lists
1 #1 Spot

11th Place



Golden Grahams
23 Pts.
3 Lists

10th Place



Froot Loops
24 Pts.
5 Lists

Holy shit, I can't believe I forgot all about Golden Grahams.

My list is so erroneous.

The great Apple Jacks lumped with these jobber cereals. Did CinnaMon get depushed because he made a mistake a few years back?

4. Apple Jacks - 13th
6. Raisin Bran - 18th
7. Honey Smacks - 43rd
8. Golden Crisp - 16th
9. Cocoa Pebbles -14th
10. Fruit Loops 13th

No love for Mr. T cereal? Sad.

9th Place



Frosted Mini Wheats
26 Pts.
5 Lists

8th Place



Corn Pops
27 Pts.
3 Lists

7th Place



Reese's Puffs
29 Pts.
5 Lists

6th Place



Lucky Charms
32 Pts.
7 Lists

Ah, Reese's Puffs. THE best puffed cereal on the planet. Still love it today.

Mini Wheats are the cereal I actually like without the milk. While i still like it in a bowl, I tend to eat them outta the box. I love drinking the milk after a bowl of Reese's Puffs.

Corn pops is one of those cereals that I love munching on as a snack but can honestly say I have never had in a bowl with milk. Mini wheats yes but I find they taste better dry. Never had an issue with cereals going soggy in milk because I usually beat them up right away but something about mini wheats and milk never clicked with me.

5th Place



Honey Nut Cheerios
35 Pts.
5 Lists
1 #1 Spot

3rd Place



Frosted Flakes
36 Pts.
6 Lists
1 #1 Spot



Fruity Pebbles
36 Pts.
4 Lists
1 #1 Spot

Corn Pops looks so plain to be ranked that high but it is very good.
HN Cheerios and Frosted Flakes are usually in my normal cereal rotation.

2. Frosted Flakes - 3rd
3. Honey Nut Cheerios - 5th
4. Apple Jacks - 13th
5. Corn Pops - 8th
6. Raisin Bran - 18th
7. Honey Smacks - 43rd
8. Golden Crisp - 16th
9. Cocoa Pebbles -14th
10. Fruit Loops 13th

2nd Place



Cap'n Crunch
37 Pts.
6 Lists

1st Place



Cinnamon Toast Crunch
57 Points
7 Lists
4 #1 Spots

Wow. The two cereals I thought wouldn't be in the top two, and they are. Not my cup of tea.

Here was my final list, BTW.


1. Honey Nut Cherrios

2. Golden Grahams

3. Sugar/Golden Crisp

4. Mini Wheats

5. Reese's Puffs

6. Frosted Cherrios

7. Honey Nut/Honey Crunch/Crunchy Nut Corn Flakes

8. Honey Bunches of Oats with Almonds

9. Multi-Grain Cherrios

10. Oatmeal Crisp Maple Nut

Also, adjusted to combine their scores, since they were both the same cereal, but scores seperately somehow, Honey/Honey Crunch/Crunchy Nut Corn Flakes would have been in a tie for 16th with 12 points.

PW has great taste in cereal the rightful champion got it in the end. I am surprised Capt. Crunch got so high. I think of all the upper ranked cereals it is the only one I never tried.

1. Cinnamon Toast Crunch - 1st
2. Frosted Flakes - 3rd
3. Honey Nut Cheerios - 5th
4. Apple Jacks - 13th
5. Corn Pops - 8th
6. Raisin Bran - 18th
7. Honey Smacks - 43rd
8. Golden Crisp - 16th
9. Cocoa Pebbles -14th
10. Fruit Loops 13th

Fucking awesome countdown, @ness! Thanks for the idea, organizing and running this thing.

I'll have to drag my list out for reference at some point.

This whole thing has made me so nostalgic. I'm really tempted to just say fuck it to my lactose intolerance and slow adult metabolism and go pound town on all these cereals again.

This countdown has sorta reinvigorated my love for cereal. I've had a bowl every day since I started this and I've even tried a few new ones. I might start doing that, sample random ones just to expand my "roster". Of course there won't be any chocolate varieties as I've never been a big chocolate guy in general. If you guys want more cereal love check out Cereal Time on Youtube. He makes 3-5 minute videos about different cereals past and present where he talks about the history and even eats them. Discovered it during the countdown and have been watching a bunch each day.

Good jorb Nessie. Definitely enjoyed following along!