1. Aaron Rodgers (tie)
1. Patrick Mahomes (tie)
3. Drew Brees 
4. Philip Rivers 
5. Jared Goff 
6. Matt Ryan 
7. Tom Brady 
8. Ben Roethlisberger 
9. Kirk Cousins 
10. Andrew Luck 
11. Cam Newton 
12. Ryan Fitzpatrick 
13. Russell Wilson 
14. Carson Wentz 
15. Deshaun Watson 
16. Andy Dalton 
17. Matthew Stafford 
18. Marcus Mariota 
19. Baker Mayfield 
20. Dak Prescott 
21. Joe Flacco 
22. Mitchell Trubisky 
23. Derek Carr 
24. Alex Smith 
25. Case Keenum 
26. Eli Manning 
27. Josh Rosen 
28. Sam Darnold 
29. Blake Bortles 
30. CJ Beathard 
31. Josh Allen 
32. Jameis Winston 

I like those rankings , off the top I think Jameis is a little low - he has shown enough flashes to be higher but it was mostly my fault for forgetting about him.

I still don't like Rivers that high - I know he's having a great year but part of my quarterback judging also goes by how fun they are to watch play and I just hate watching that man throw ducks all day.

I'd put Darnold over Rosen since Rosen has better targets to throw to as of late which have helped dip Darnolds stats lately but not much to gripe about other than that.

Fitzpatrick is way too high though, guy is putting up throwing yards purely due to offense and who he is throwing too.

Pretty harsh with no Tannehill on list somewhere. I hate Tannehill but you can't tell me Beathard is better than him.

Don't love this list. If it's based on current form, Rodgers above Brees, Mahomes and Goff is inaccurate and if it's based on overall ability then of course Rodgers is number one, but Fitzpatrick certainly isn't better than Wilson, Wentz or Watson. Seems a bit muddled.

Nov 13, 2018 18:32:04 GMT Todd said:

Don't love this list. If it's based on current form, Rodgers above Brees, Mahomes and Goff is inaccurate and if it's based on overall ability then of course Rodgers is number one, but Fitzpatrick certainly isn't better than Wilson, Wentz or Watson. Seems a bit muddled.

It is a bit muddled because I think me @admit had different idea's in mind when making our list. I tried to make my list based on more than just the first ten games of this season (I obvious took this season into account as well) but I took more of a total view of the quarterbacks. If I was going to pick any of these quarterbacks to finish the season for me sort of thing. 

List loses credibility with Rodgers at the top. He ain’t doing shit to be above Brees, Brady or Rivers right now. Tied with Mahomes too? Bogus list.

Nov 13, 2018 19:04:53 GMT KING KID said:

List loses credibility with Rodgers at the top. He ain’t doing shit to be above Brees, Brady or Rivers right now. Tied with Mahomes too? Bogus list.

Fuck off.

It’s not my fault that you being a homer has made the list lose credibility and turn into shit.

And it's not my fault that your best contribution or criticism comes in the style of a tweet by our douchebag in office. So either come up with something actual intellectual or constructive to say or fuck off and stay out of the thread. That's how it's going to go , don't bother responding otherwise - please and thanks.

You complain about Trump, but as a “boss” of this forum, your attitude to those that disagree is extremely similar. No? Sounds a lot like you hate yourself.

As for adding discussion, Aaron Rodgers isn’t even top 5. Yeah, he’s playing with heart and playing injured and give him a cookie for that but he doesn’t belong in the same breath as Mahomes and Brees this season. He’s not even the best QB in his division right now. Trubisky is outperforming him. Maybe he’d have a better finish to the year, but that’s going to need Jordy Nelson to come out of retirement. Oh, right....

Nov 13, 2018 20:30:49 GMT KING KID said:

You complain about Trump, but as a “boss” of this forum, your attitude to those that disagree is extremely similar. No? Sounds a lot like you hate yourself.

As for adding discussion, Aaron Rodgers isn’t even top 5. Yeah, he’s playing with heart and playing injured and give him a cookie for that but he doesn’t belong in the same breath as Mahomes and Brees this season. He’s not even the best QB in his division right now. Trubisky is outperforming him. Maybe he’d have a better finish to the year, but that’s going to need Jordy Nelson to come out of retirement. Oh, right....

I'm not the boss of any forum , if I were and anything like your boy I would of built a wall around this shit a long time ago to keep your ass out. 

And you lose instant credibility when you bring up Trubisky because you OBVIOUSLY haven't seen him actually play , the kid is a front runner and overall his statistics aren't even better than Rodgers aside from two more touchdowns. He has have six more interceptions. Having watched damn near every Bears game this year I have zero fear of Trubisky. 

The idea that a season where he is on pace for over 5000 yards passing , 34 touchdowns and ONE INTERCEPTION is bad is fucking laughable. Half of that being on one leg - and most of it being down two of his top three receivers and playing most of the offensive sets with a 5th and 6th round pick starting at receiver. No those numbers aren't as flashy as Brees or Mahomes but they also have incredible systems to work in. So take your cookie and shove it up your ass you wannabe talking head. 

What does it take to be a talking head? Really? A YouTube channel? Because if I wanted to be a talking head, I could be one. Instead, I choose to contribute to this forum and prove you wrong time and time again. Remember our 2/3 bet? How’s Philly and GB looking in that playoff picture?

And making injury excuses doesn’t make someone a top QB in the NFL. Neither does complaining about their system. Those are all reasons he’s not a top QB. Nobody is questioning Rodgers as a person, even though he distances himself from his family and isn’t that great of a person either. He’s just not the top QB in the NFL this season and the fact that you can’t let your hometown hero be second to anyone proves that you can’t put together a QB list without it being tainted by #12 Cum stains.

Nov 13, 2018 21:07:56 GMT KING KID said:

What does it take to be a talking head? Really? A YouTube channel? Because if I wanted to be a talking head, I could be one. Instead, I choose to contribute to this forum and prove you wrong time and time again. Remember our 2/3 bet? How’s Philly and GB looking in that playoff picture?

And making injury excuses doesn’t make someone a top QB in the NFL. Neither does complaining about their system. Those are all reasons he’s not a top QB. Nobody is questioning Rodgers as a person, even though he distances himself from his family and isn’t that great of a person either. He’s just not the top QB in the NFL this season and the fact that you can’t let your hometown hero be second to anyone proves that you can’t put together a QB list without it being tainted by #12 Cum stains.

Are you retarded? I clearly said I didn’t rank based on just this season and you have no idea where and and HR had any guys ranked.

I’m done with you narrative and the very fact you have to instantly go to Rodgers personal life proves you’re a hairbrained twat who can’t stay on task.

NFL QB Rankings corner- Week 10

“I didn’t rank them on this season....”

Oh ok.

My only complaint is that Matt Barkley is not #1

Gotta agree with Todd and Kid on this one. Rodgers at #1 for a week 10 list of QB's is weak. Brees, Mahomes and Rivers have easily played better football than Rodgers this season and I could easily argue that Goff and Ryan have as well. Not Brady though, not after he shit the bed this past week.

Also having Fitz above Wilson??? No way, not in a million years.


Finally how is Jameis low??  He's been the drizzling shits this season, and it wasn't like he was  a brilliant QB to begin with.     His spot on the list is legit.

Well this made for a good read this morning!

#12 cum stains :lol:

Shit like this is why I left this site in the first place.

I’m confused about what the lists goals were, but they can’t all be winners so I’m not bothered. Plus my boy Mahomes is at number one!

Nov 14, 2018 2:56:43 GMT mikec said:

I’m confused about what the lists goals were, but they can’t all be winners so I’m not bothered. Plus my boy Mahomes is at number one!

Yeah, as UT has already said I think we have got a little bit muddled up. His perspective of adding in "who you'd rather have if you could choose any QB to play for you the rest of the season" makes some sense but does create more subjectivity I think.

Here's my list, specifically on play so far this season:

1. Mahomes
2. Brees
3. Rodgers
4. Rivers
5. Ryan
6. Goff
7. Cousins
8. Roethlisberger
9. Fitzpatrick
10. Brady
11. Newton
12. Luck
13. Wentz
14. Wilson
15. Watson
16. Dalton
17. Stafford
18. Mayfield
19. Mariota
20. Prescott
21. Flacco
22. Carr
23. Trubisky
24. Smith
25. Manning
26. Keenum
27. Bortles
28. Rosen
29. Darnold
30. Beathard
31. Winston
32. Allen

Nov 14, 2018 2:48:35 GMT Blindy said:

Shit like this is why I left this site in the first place.

:rolleyes:

Nov 14, 2018 4:44:10 GMT UT said:

Nov 14, 2018 2:48:35 GMT Blindy said:

Shit like this is why I left this site in the first place.

Don't you be rolling your eyes at our resident NFL scout! 

Why in the world do ya'll have Fitzpatrick so damn high though?

Nov 14, 2018 5:14:14 GMT shinobimusashi said:

Why in the world do ya'll have Fitzpatrick so damn high though?

Have you seen him play this season? He has the second highest YPA of all time.

PFF has him 8th, he's 8th in passer rating too. Tack his YPA on to that, I would say the better argument is that he should be higher based just on this season.

Nov 13, 2018 19:04:53 GMT KING KID said:

List loses credibility with Rodgers at the top. He ain’t doing shit to be above Brees, Brady or Rivers right now. Tied with Mahomes too? Bogus list.

I'd agree with Brees, Mahomes, and maybe Rivers, but he's above Brady...tied in TD's, but 6 less INT's, higher QBR...with an inferior team.

Really, as of this week, Brady should be below Ben. Ben's over Brady across the board, except the tie in INT's. He's just been on.

Interesting notes on quarterbacks in general this season - have a look at the passer stats on PFR across the board. Quarterbacks are putting up ridiculous numbers across the board, everyone in the top 10 is having an insane season. Surely something needs to be done about it.

Nov 14, 2018 10:23:47 GMT Todd said:

Interesting notes on quarterbacks in general this season - have a look at the passer stats on PFR across the board. Quarterbacks are putting up ridiculous numbers across the board, everyone in the top 10 is having an insane season. Surely something needs to be done about it.

It's no secret, the NFL paradigm right now is WAY too QB friendly.    The fact that RYAN FUCKING FITZPATRICK is a legit top 10 QB this season tells you everything to know.   There has never been an easier time in the NFL history to play QB than it is now. 

A lot of people think I'm being a bit of a curmudgeon when I say I don't respect today's QB's nearly as much, but how can I?   They're playing Madden on easy mode right now while defenders are playing on the highest difficulty.  

First thing that needs to be done is to get rid of this ridiculous body weight rule on QB's.   Maybe keep it for hits after the QB has thrown the ball, but to call it on legit sacks is ridiculous.    Next they need to let defensive backs actually cover without throwing pass interference at the drop of a hat. 

Also tells you how much Nathan Peterman sucks to have such a crappy season in such a QB friendly league. 

I watched a little bit of the Bucs this year but wasn't really impressed with Fitzpatrick, he's won 2 games and is ranked over guys who have more passing yards, more wins, and fewer interceptions. I have an issue with him being ranked over Watson who has won games playing behind bottom 5 o-line winning with broken chest/punctured lung with more passing yards fewer interceptions and more game winning drives/4th quarter comebacks than Fitzpatrick. He's an interception throwing machine and I predict his stats fall off sharply once he gets some games now that we're in the thick of the season where shit gets real, he shined early on in the first part of the year that is like an extension of pre-season ever since they limited practice in the 2011 CBA.

Nov 13, 2018 22:17:46 GMT thereallt said:

Gotta agree with Todd and Kid on this one. Rodgers at #1 for a week 10 list of QB's is weak. Brees, Mahomes and Rivers have easily played better football than Rodgers this season and I could easily argue that Goff and Ryan have as well. Not Brady though, not after he shit the bed this past week.

Also having Fitz above Wilson??? No way, not in a million years.


Finally how is Jameis low??  He's been the drizzling shits this season, and it wasn't like he was  a brilliant QB to begin with.     His spot on the list is legit.

And yet if you were playing a game tomorrow , independent of scheme and weapons around them - you'd probably take Rodgers.