Nighty

1. The Last of Us
2. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
3. Metal Gear Solid's 4: Guns of the Patriots
4. Horizon Zero Dawn
5. Ico
6. Resident Evil 3
7. Shenmue 2
8. The Order: 1886
9. Deus Ex
10. Spec Ops: The Line
11. Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic
12. The Wolf Among Us
13. Middle-Earth: Shadow of Modor
14. A Way Out
15. Until Dawn
16. Firewatch

CM Punk'd

1. Super Mario Brothers 3
2. Grand Theft Auto 5
3. Uncharted 4: A Thief's End
4. Resident Evil 2
5. Tetris
6. The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess
7. Perfect Dark
8. Diddy Kong Racing
9. Mortal Kombat 2
10. Command and Conquer: Red Alert 2
11. Harvest Moon
12. Sonic CD
13. F-Zero
14. Rise of the Tomb Raider
15. The Sims 4
16. SSX Tricky

Both fantastic lists, Im going to have to go with CM Punk’d as DKR and MK are among my top 10 favourite games of all time.

Love MGS4 and KOTOR on Nighty’s list & really want to play Spec Ops: the line.

1. The Last of Us - 9.5
2. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt - 9.5
3. Metal Gear Solid's 4: Guns of the Patriots - 8.5
4. Horizon Zero Dawn - 8
5. Ico
6. Resident Evil 3 - 7
7. Shenmue 2
8. The Order: 1886 - 4
9. Deus Ex - 8
10. Spec Ops: The Line
11. Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic
- 9
12. The Wolf Among Us - 8.5
13. Middle-Earth: Shadow of Modor - 8.5
14. A Way Out
15. Until Dawn - 8
16. Firewatch

88.5

1. Super Mario Brothers 3 - 10
2. Grand Theft Auto 5 - 9.5
3. Uncharted 4: A Thief's End - 9
4. Resident Evil 2 - 8.5
5. Tetris - 9
6. The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess - 8.5
7. Perfect Dark - 8
8. Diddy Kong Racing - 7
9. Mortal Kombat 2 - 7
10. Command and Conquer: Red Alert 2
11. Harvest Moon - 7.5
12. Sonic CD - 8.5
13. F-Zero
14. Rise of the Tomb Raider - 8.5
15. The Sims 4
16. SSX Tricky

101

Nighty's list is much more my speed, CM has some great picks, but more that I could do without.

Nighty

1. The Last of Us
2. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
3. Metal Gear Solid's 4: Guns of the Patriots
4. Horizon Zero Dawn
5. Ico
6. Resident Evil 3
7. Shenmue 2
8. The Order: 1886
9. Deus Ex
10. Spec Ops: The Line
11. Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic
12. The Wolf Among Us
13. Middle-Earth: Shadow of Modor
14. A Way Out
15. Until Dawn
16. Firewatch

CM Punk'd

1. Super Mario Brothers 3
2. Grand Theft Auto 5
3. Uncharted 4: A Thief's End
4. Resident Evil 2
5. Tetris
6. The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess
7. Perfect Dark
8. Diddy Kong Racing
9. Mortal Kombat 2
10. Command and Conquer: Red Alert 2
11. Harvest Moon
12. Sonic CD
13. F-Zero
14. Rise of the Tomb Raider
15. The Sims 4
16. SSX Tricky

My top 5 of those goes:
1. Last of Us
2. Metal Gear Solid 4
3. RE2
4. GTAV
5. Shenmue 2

Only one from CM Punk'd.

It was all fun and games until Nighty threw Ico and Shenmue in his list and offended me.

CM Punk'd put together a pretty good list, love the Sonic CD shout out, it was the only Sonic game I got to play growing up.

@nighty had Firewatch, which I've been intrigued to give a shot. But everything else... Never even heard of, much less played.

CM Punk'd meanwhile has some near perfection picks for me:
Super Mario Brothers 3
Grand Theft Auto 5
Tetris
Perfect Dark
Diddy Kong Racing
Mortal Kombat 2
Command and Conquer: Red Alert 2
Harvest Moon
F-Zero

Killed it.

This is such a hard one!

I love The Last of Us, The Wolf Among Us, A Way Out and Until Dawn. On the other hand I love Uncharted 4, GTAV, The Sims 4, and Rise of the Tomb Raider! 4 super solid picks each.

In the end Nighty ended up winning due to recently starting Firewatch, and The Witcher and Horizon Zero Dawn are on my too be played soon list

From Nighty’s list, I have played The Last of Us, Metal Gear Solid's 4: Guns of the Patriots, Horizon Zero Dawn, The Order: 1886, Deus Ex, The Wolf Among Us, A Way Out, and Until Dawn.

I enjoyed all of them but most of the suffer from one time experiences, short experiences, or both. Favorite from the list is definitely Horizon Zero Dawn closely followed by The Wolf Among Us. Until Dawn is the only thing on the list I believe I played more than once which was for the different ending and trophies. And replayed the ending of A Way Out because the person want to see what happen if

SPOILER: Click to show

won the final shoot out.

From CM Punk'd’s list, I have played Super Mario Brothers 3, Grand Theft Auto 5, Uncharted 4: A Thief's End, Tetris, Diddy Kong Racing, Mortal Kombat 2, Sonic CD, and Rise of the Tomb Raider.

Probably played SMB3 and Tetris hundreds of times over the years. Being they are older games you couldn’t really save so didn’t beat everything back then. GTA5 went back in the fun direction which was a good change to me after GTA4. GTA4 was the first GTA I beat but was the one I had the least fun with. Mortal Kombat 2 was the first fighting game I was decent at since I couldn’t do quarter circle forward rotation. And I remember how ton of people use to gather around that arcade machine at the mall. And doing well with Mileena and beating someone with her fatality the first time felt amazing. I only beat one person that day but beating just one with everyone around for the first time felt great. I think I ended up with Diddy Kart Racing by accident when I heard everyone talking about Mario Kart. It was pretty fun but don’t remember what lead to me getting it Sonic CD having actually songs for the first was definitely a video game milestone for me. All Uncharteds all great but I think one of the best moments was when Nate’s daughter realize what badasses her parents were. And while I like Tomb Raider puzzles, I can’t tell you what happen in each one by title.

Both really great lists, seriously such a hard choice. Looking them both over though, Nighty's first two choices would probably be in my top 10 games of all time list, were I to make one.  Mario was never my thing (sorry, abuse me all you like) but GTA 5 is a masterpiece and I'm currently playing Uncharted 4 (which I think I love the story of best of all the Uncharted games).  

Looking at the rest of their lists, Nighty has more games there that I've actually played, although CM has Sims 4 and Rise of the Tomb Raider, both of which I love.  On balance though, I'm going with Nighty.

Very tricky, but CM Punk'd has a few more games I like, and a few less games that I don't care for at all, when compared to @nighty.

Come to think of it, I haven't played a single game from Nighty's list, although The Witcher 3, Ico and Deus Ex are among the favourites on my to-play list, while I imagine I would really like games like Shadow of Mordor and Resident Evil 3.

This was an easy choice. Nighty was the clear winner.

The Last of Us, The Witcher, Metal Gear Solid, Horizon Zero Dawn, Ico, Resident Evil, Shenmue, Deus Ex, Knights of the Old Republic (one of my favorites of ALL TIME), AND Shadow of Modor are all amazing.

Meanwhile, Punk'd has GTA, Resident Evil, Uncharted, the worst Zelda, and Command and Conquer of games I care about. Maybe the Sonic is good...I don't think I've played that one. He also has Tetris on his list which is like a negative impact to bore me to death.

I don't suspect there will be more of a one-sided matchup in this tournament for me, but I am surprised to see Punk is winning.

Easy choice for me and it probably says a lot as far as me being a gamer goes.

CM Punk'd List

Super Mario Brothers 3
Grand Theft Auto 5
Tetris
The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess
Perfect Dark
Mortal Kombat 2
F-Zero

@nighty List

Nothing, I've played absolutely nothing from his picks.

Did a count and both lists have an even number of games I love.

But @nighty has my favourite game of all time in TLOU so he wins by a hair.

I am pleased by this result, keep it up.

CM Punk'd wins

Please steal one of Nighty's games and drop one of your own. 

GG @nighty

I will drop Command & COnquer: Red Alert 2, and add The Last of Us.