pduh

QB - Drew Brees  

RB - Ezekial Elliott  

WR - Julio Jones  

WR - JuJu Smith-Schuster  

WR - Deebo Samuel  

TE - OJ Howard  

LT - Trent Williams   

LG - Joe Thuney  

C - Brandon Linder  

RG - David DeCastro  

RT - Orlando Brown Jr  

DE - Myles Garrett  

DE - Cameron Jordan  

DT - Aaron Donald  

LB - Za'Darius Smith  

LB - Dont'a Hightower  

LB - CJ Mosley  

LB - Myles Jack  

CB - Shaquill Griffin  

CB - Patrick Peterson  

S - Jamal Adams  

S - Anthony Harris  

K - Mason Crosby  

P - Cameron Johnston  

KR - Richie James

Real LT

QB - Russell Wilson
RB - Saquon Barkley

WR - Mike Evans

WR - Jarvis Landry

WR - Brandin Cooks

TE - Travis Kelce

LT - Tyron Smith

LG - Joel Bitonio

C - Ryan Jensen

RG - Kelechi Osemele

RT - Jake Matthews

DE - Joey Bosa
DT - Chris Jones

DT - Kyle Williams

LB - DeMario Davis

LB - Shaquil Barrett

LB - Sean Lee

LB - Anthony Barr

CB - Marcus Peters

CB - Xavien Howard

S - Tyrann Mathieu

S - Rashad Jones

K - Josh Lambo

P - Brett Kern

KR - Cordarrelle Patterson

I see the main advantages going to pduh with wide receivers, pass rush and safety. LT has a massive advantage at tight end and also has better special teamers.

If they faced each other I see Garrett, Jordan, Donald and Z. Smith bullying LT's offensive line, particularly on their weaker right side - and that's too much for even Wilson to overcome. When pduh's team has the ball I'm not sure LT has anyone that can cover Julio Jones. Maybe prime Xavien Howard could have filled that role but I'm unsure whether that player still exists.

I'll have to come back to this. LT is better on offense and pduh on defense. This is an incredibly close, high-quality match that I'll give a bit more thought to.

I misread thereallt's name in the thread title as RT and clicked into this to vote against him on principle.

But then I realized I misread, and it was thereallt --NOT RT-- and so my spite voting wouldn't be warranted.

In the end though, my vote will always go with JuJu.

pduh stunned everyone by going Aaron Donald #1 overall and then put together a roster that’s great enough to win the whole thing. His defense would make this a Russ/Barkley/Kelce game and that’s not going to be enough to win.

Pduh gets my vote. Final score 27-17.

Yeah but Pduh is horribly mis-using Donald. He should either a 3 tech in a 4-3 algnment or a 5 tech in a 3-4 alignment. Putting him a nose tackle severely limits his playmaking ability. Cam Jordan and Myles Garrett are also normally 4-3 ends, but they are big enough that they could probably make the adjustment to a 3-4. Still though they would eat quite a few double teams rushing out of a 3-4.   Z.Smith would have to be main clean up guy the way Pduh's defense is constructed.

Jul 13, 2020 2:09:41 GMT thereallt said:

Yeah but Pduh is horribly mis-using Donald. He should either a 3 tech in a 4-3 algnment or a 5 tech in a 3-4 alignment. Putting him a nose tackle severely limits his playmaking ability. Cam Jordan and Myles Garrett are also normally 4-3 ends, but they are big enough that they could probably make the adjustment to a 3-4. Still though they would eat quite a few double teams rushing out of a 3-4.   Z.Smith would have to be main clean up guy the way Pduh's defense is constructed.

I don't want to harp on about this having already mentioned it previously, but this is the line of thinking I can't get away from currently. pduh passed on Mahomes and Wilson to take a defensive player, albeit one of the GOATs, and put him in the wrong position. I'm going to give the edge to LT here. He has the better offense and that gets it done in the modern-day NFL.

Terry Bradshaw hands the trophy to pduh  as gold and burgundy confetti rains down from above