Post by Baker on Jul 19, 2020 2:21:21 GMT
The Backstory to the Backstory
I started a thread yesterday with a big old rambling post pwcom.proboards.com/thread/3369/unpopular-opinions-bad-takes-disconnect?page=1&scrollTo=134057 just to set the stage for today's topic.
The major purpose of yesterday's post was to show how limited my perspective was when it came to what was popular in wrestling while I was growing up. I basically judged what was popular (or unpopular) based on my own idiosyncratic tastes and the opinions of a handful of friends/acquaintances. And I'm not sure these other people were "normal" wrestling fans either. For example, my closest wrestling fan friend from about mid 93-early 95 was a guy I quite accurately refer to as "Matt The IRS Fan." Yep. An IRS fan. Totally normal stuff....
I felt it was important to set the stage the way I did because I would never (re)book anything I personally could not believe in. So as "out there" as my Lex Luger superpush, or this upcoming Mr. Wonderful rebook may appear in 2020, these are things I genuinely could have seen happening back in the day. Hell, most of these rebooking projects are just expanded versions of things I envisioned in my head a quarter century ago. Anyway.....
The wrestling business was booming by the Summer of '95 (or so I thought) simply because I had more wresting fan friends than ever before. Counting myself, our main group consisted of 7 hardcore super fans who watched all the wrestling we could (then spent the rest of the week discussing what we had watched) and 2 other casual fans (including a rare Smoking Gunns enthusiast!) who watched mainly just because the rest of us did. For the core group of 7, our lives pretty much revolved around Wrestling, Exosquad(!), and Courtball, with Wrestling coming first.
Getting all 7-9 of us to agree on ANYTHING wrestling-related was a daunting proposition. We were a very opinionated bunch with an extremely diverse set of opinions who argued about practically everything. On the far end of one spectrum, you had me with my oddball tastes and predominately heel loving ways. On the far end of the other spectrum, you had more traditional babyface fans like my brother and a few others (although even these more traditional fans were not without their idiosyncrasies). Then you had a few people in the middle of the two extremes who liked a mix of face and heel wrestlers. A few were growing into early workrate snobs, while I still thought the money was in big, mean, nasty fatties battling heroic musclemen. A wrestler being "over" within our group typically meant people argued over them....
Let's use Razor and his Opponents as an example. The bulk of my wrestling fan clique loved "The Bad Guy." I personally could not stand the man who oozed machismo. Instead, I was a huge fan of his rivals- Dean Douglas, Goldust, and the team of Sid & The Kid. So Razor's matches became heated affairs with the pro and anti Razor factions hanging on the edge of our seats during his matches. Applying modern terminology to 1995 logic, this meant Razor and his Opponents were "over" because we were all deeply invested in the outcome of their matches.
Only a select few wrestlers managed to unify all 7-9 of us. So, again applying modern terminology to 1995 logic, this meant those wrestlers were not just over, but over like rover. Getting all of us to agree on anything was a minor miracle. As best I can remember, only 4 wrestlers were over with all of us in late 95-early 96. Let's take a look at this Fantastic Four.....
The first wrestler with unanimous consent was.....Barry Horowitz :lol: Yep. We all LOVED the ultimate underdog. Hell, Barry beating Skip is literally what kickstarted this neighborhood wrestling boom! Not a single one of us would have batted an eye if Barry won the IC Title, or Tag Titles with Hakushi. In fact, this is what we WANTED to happen. I personally thought it was inevitable, and anxiously awaited that day. I will even go a step further and say I would have been totally fine with Barry winning the WWF Championship! With my logic being, "If you're going to do a Rocky story, you might as well go all the way."
A few months later Dean Malenko would generate unanimous consent. Dean was another underdog, albeit one of a different stripe than Howitzer Horowitz. Horowitz was a storyline underdog. Malenko was a real life underdog. Barry turned the "loser" gimmick into a feel good push. Despite being so good, Malenko was more like a real life loser...or at least a non-factor. So we latched onto him as Our Guy. Like Horowitz, a lot of Dean's appeal came from rooting for the underdog. So him beating Ohtani for the Cruiserweight Title on humble Worldwide was a HUGE moment for us. Our guy had made it! Then he even started getting pay per view matches! Hooray! But the good times would not last. Dean's unanimous consent evaporated when stupid Rey Mysterio Jr. debuted and half my clique defected to Team Rey after being wowed by their shiny new toy. Sad. This lead to the Great Rey/Dean Divide and a series of heated matches with total investment.
Undertaker was another wrestler we all liked. 'Taker had always been popular in my neighborhood. He was basically God to my much smaller 93-94 wrestling fan clique. And while we did unanimously like 'Taker in 95-96, it was honestly a step down from the love he got from that different set of friends in 93-94.
And the 4th wrestler with unanimous consent is none other than the man of the hour.....
Mr. Wonderful Paul Orndorff
To be continued....