pretty simple thread just rank the mainstream wrestling companies by the quality of their respective women's divisions .

For me it works out like this

1. WWE- WWE is kind of #1 by default at this point and really coasts by just having so many high quality wrestlers signed even though the booking really isn't good at all. It's hard to have a truly bad division when you have the likes of Io, Meiko, Asuka, Bayley, Bianca, Rhea, Zoey, Sarray, Nikki, Ember, and Kay Lee ray among others signed to the promotion. The booking isn't great however especially on the main roster where things are really uninteresting.

2. Impact- Kind of the inverse of WWE really. I'd say the booking and storytelling is pretty decent , but the roster just lacks in terms of top tier exciting  in-ring talents. Deonna , Jordynne, Kiera , Tasha, Taylor, and Rachael are all rally nice talents but none of them have consistently produced matches at the level the top talents in WWE especially in the two NXt's produce on a fairly regular basis which isn't entirely their fault for reasons I will get into in a bit. Outside of those 6 the roster is composed of some pretty bland talents in the ring who are all kind of slow.Another problem I have is Impact's tendency to focus on quantity over quality in terms of matches especially on PPV. Sometimes on one of the impacts specials there will be three women's matches  which sounds good in theory  but they tend to eat into each other's runtimes resulting in matches that don't quite reach their full potential and are good but not great.Impact also is very slow when it comes to adding new fresh talent, they go through hiring droughts pretty regularly and even when they bring in new talents some times it's only for a very short time like Alexa Nicole or Lacey Ryan (Zoey Stark) . You might say Impact can't afford to consistently bolster and replenish their roster but you have companies like ROH and NWA using exciting new talents on their roster. Still the division isn't bad per say and  it's better than the other non-wwe options.

3. AEW- In terms of pure talent on the roster AEW is probably second only to WWE, but the booking and just general usage of the division is incredibly inconsistent and just plain bad oftentimes.  Every once in awhile they'll have a really nice match or an entertaining promo/segment with the women. 

        
4. NWA- The ppv  matches are generally high quality and the roster has some intriguing young talent on it with some nice veterans as well ( but who knows how long the likes of Rosa and Deeb will stay on the show), but the usage/booking of the women on the weekly show feels like something out of 10 years ago with really short matches and segments.


5. ROH- Their track record with WOH is really bad but the tournament they're doing now seems interesting and has some nice talent in it. It's hard to look past how bad the WOH division has been booked and presented in the past however. I could see this easily moving up if things continue on their current path however.

1. Impact does the most with what they have usually doing multiple segments for women and usually get the entire division in something.
2. WWE has the most high profile women of anyone but the problem is you can't push everyone at once and someone needs to lose. When they care they care when they don't they don't
3. NWA I am cheating here and counting NWA at AEW as NWA. From the little I have seem they treat their women like a big deal. And two of the best women that help boost AEW only came there due to pandemic issues
4. AEW is getting better about doing something with their women. But normally their is one match for women max on the show which is usually a lot shorter then all of the rest matches on the show. It is normally in the bathroom break spot which is the match before the main event.

Everyone is on a pretty even level in my eyes - it's hard to be particularly positive about any company right now. Each promotion comes through with a really strong match every few months or so but no one is booking anything remotely interesting or buzzworthy, and they all drag down their elite talent with others who are not good.

Jul 2, 2021 1:35:54 GMT X-zero said:

1. Impact does the most with what they have usually doing multiple segments for women and usually get the entire division in something.
2. WWE has the most high profile women of anyone but the problem is you can't push everyone at once and someone needs to lose. When they care they care when they don't they don't
3. NWA I am cheating here and counting NWA at AEW as NWA. From the little I have seem they treat their women like a big deal. And two of the best women that help boost AEW only came there due to pandemic issues
4. AEW is getting better about doing something with their women. But normally their is one match for women max on the show which is usually a lot shorter then all of the rest matches on the show. It is normally in the bathroom break spot which is the match before the main event.

The knockouts just don't produce enough high level matches  regularly enough to be above WWE imo. Meiko vs KLR 1 and 2, Meiko vs Aolfe, Zoey vs Sarray, Io vs Raquel, Raquel vs Rhea, Sasha vs Bianca, Bianca vs Bayley Hell in a Cell , The Way vs Ember and Shotzi are all quite a bit better than anything Impact ha produced this year thus far . Deonna's reign has honestly been pretty disappointing outside of her matches with Jordynne and maybe Taya because Impact hasn't given her much to work with at all.  

Jul 2, 2021 1:46:18 GMT @admin said:

Everyone is on a pretty even level in my eyes - it's hard to be particularly positive about any company right now. Each promotion comes through with a really strong match every few months or so but no one is booking anything remotely interesting or buzzworthy, and they all drag down their elite talent with others who are not good.

Yeah none of my descriptions of the company with particularly positive  either. No division is overly good right now. I just like what WWE produces because imo they have more high tier talents and give them more time for their matches than say Impact or AEW. So I can enjoy the matches the likes of Meiko are producing while ignoring the booking or lack thereof.  

Jul 2, 2021 2:15:33 GMT dex02 said:

Jul 2, 2021 1:35:54 GMT X-zero said:

1. Impact does the most with what they have usually doing multiple segments for women and usually get the entire division in something.
2. WWE has the most high profile women of anyone but the problem is you can't push everyone at once and someone needs to lose. When they care they care when they don't they don't
3. NWA I am cheating here and counting NWA at AEW as NWA. From the little I have seem they treat their women like a big deal. And two of the best women that help boost AEW only came there due to pandemic issues
4. AEW is getting better about doing something with their women. But normally their is one match for women max on the show which is usually a lot shorter then all of the rest matches on the show. It is normally in the bathroom break spot which is the match before the main event.

The knockouts just don't produce enough high level matches  regularly enough to be above WWE imo. Meiko vs KLR 1 and 2, Meiko vs Aolfe, Zoey vs Sarray, Io vs Raquel, Raquel vs Rhea, Sasha vs Bianca, Bianca vs Bayley Hell in a Cell , The Way vs Ember and Shotzi are all quite a bit better than anything Impact ha produced this year thus far . Deonna's reign has honestly been pretty disappointing outside of her matches with Jordynne and maybe Taya because Impact hasn't given her much to work with at all.  

I go by averages since WWE is a whole lot bigger. It has 7 hours of weekly TV plus how ever long nXt uk is. They should have the most high quality matches.

But nothing in Impact feels bad too me. WWE stuff with Alexa is bad even more so since they are killing Shayna rep that was built in nXt. They forget about tag team champions have the time. The matches from the Lana saga.

If WWE was judged by brands instead a whole I probably would rank some brand at one because I believe most of what pull it down in my eyes is Raw.

The KOs have been a lot of fun. I love that something for everyone to be involved in. AEW'S division used to be awful but, they are steadily improving.

I think the biggest difference between WWE and all the others is roster size and the different brands. The roster size allows for different matches and and the different brand help keep things fresh. The main problem with WWE is outside of the main storylines everything else is random.

Impact is by far the best at keeping everyone involved in someway. Problem is the roster is small and most of the ladies have been there awhile. Feel like a lot of been there done that. The division as a whole lacks freshness. Deonna has been a great but seems to have run through everyone over the past year. Rachael has been a nice addition but she's still pretty new.

AWE outside of Britt they have no clue.

I have not fallowed the others.