I've never seen Kick-Ass so I couldn't rate it.

Yeah I skipped out on this list because I assumed they had to be based on a comic, there’s too much discussion over grey area with these lists.

The Watchmen is my favourite followed closely by The Crow.

Scott Pilgrim is one of the worst films I’ve ever seen.

Scott Pilgrim is one of the worst films I’ve ever seen.

What did you hate about it?

2. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 

Wise man say: "Forgiveness is divine, but never pay full price for late pizza." ~ Michaelangelo 

Released 

1990 

Credits 

Director: Steve Barron 

Writer: Kevin Eastman 

Writer: Peter Laird 

Cast 

Judith Hoag (April O'Neal)

Elias Koteas (Casey Jones) 

Josh Pais (Raphael)

Brian Tochi (Leonardo)

Corey Feldman (Donatello)

Robbie Rist (Michaelangelo)

Critical 

6.7/10 (IMDB)

40% (RT Critics)

80% (RT Audience)

Box Office 

Domestic Gross: $135,265,915 

Worldwide Gross: $201,965,915 

Kind of surprised TMNT scored this well, I had it just outside of my top 10, as I found the original good but not great by any means.

Also yet another IP Michael Bay has smeared with feces.

Jun 6, 2018 16:32:51 GMT thereallt said:

Kind of surprised TMNT scored this well, I had it just outside of my top 10, as I found the original good but not great by any means.

Also yet another IP Michael Bay has smeared with feces.

I'm not surprised. Think of the average age of the people that submitted lists and that should tell you all you need to know.

And the movie still totally holds up. I watched it again last year and it's still so dope.

I don't even know where to start with this iconic movie , it was my #1 with a bullet and if/when we do top movies of all time it is a serious contender for my #1 movie of all time and is a lock for the top three. It's an age thing for sure as I was caught up in the TMNT wave that crushed in the nineties (130 million in 1990?!) and it continues to influence my life today as I still have a massive turtle obsession and collection. This is the movie and thing that started it all. A lot of people have Star Wars , or Trek or whatever - I have the Ninja Turtles. They are the best.

The movie itself is a perfect blend of darkness and comedy with some great bit plays by Casey , April and Splinter. The scene around the campfire still gives me chills and I love the ending where they all come together. Just a perfect movie for me.

Jun 6, 2018 16:32:51 GMT thereallt said:

Kind of surprised TMNT scored this well, I had it just outside of my top 10, as I found the original good but not great by any means.

Also yet another IP Michael Bay has smeared with feces.

Those are so many fighting words in one post.

I love the TMNT cartoon, but I feel all of the movies (originals & Bay ones) are bad.

I figured it would be the top spot. Truth be told outside of the original viewing in the theatre I don't think I ever saw it again. A re watch is in order. Despite that I think I had it high on my list even if I remember nuffin.

Jun 6, 2018 17:25:52 GMT SM said:

I love the TMNT cartoon, but I feel all of the movies (originals & Bay ones) are bad.

I think it's time we finally banned SM. Truth be told I've had enough of his shit over the years.

Jun 6, 2018 17:43:18 GMT UT said:

Jun 6, 2018 17:25:52 GMT SM said:

I love the TMNT cartoon, but I feel all of the movies (originals & Bay ones) are bad.

I think it's time we finally banned SM. Truth be told I've had enough of his shit over the years.

Not my fault the majority of you are wrong. 

What is wrong with you people? If TMNT didn't finish in the top 3 I was going to question your judgment, but I'm doing that anyway with these comments.

And you know what? I'm gonna say it: the second Michael Bay turtles movie isn't terrible. Will I watch it again? No. Was it a great movie? No. But was it better than Turtles In Time? Yes.

Jun 6, 2018 17:25:52 GMT SM said:

I love the TMNT cartoon, but I feel all of the movies (originals & Bay ones) are bad.

The original was the only one that was any good.     The sequel was terrible and both Michael Bay movies are pure garbage.  

Secret of the Ooze was...ok. They went for the kid-friendly route which is why it wasn't as good. That sucked, but I get it. Gotta get the biggest audience you can, especially back then when Disney was releasing a blockbuster cartoon every year.

Secret of the Ooze was my #2 and another contender for my overall top ten(?).

Place and time again and as a kid I probably enjoyed it more because of how light it was. And it had Vanilla Ice dropping some sick bars.

As for BOTH Bay remakes , I'll also stand by them for what they were and the first one also made my list further down. I'll consume anything TMNT and I thought that Mikey was incredible in both of those and him being my favorite - I'll fight for both those movies. The most jarring part was getting used to the aesthetics of the turtles but they'll never be as perfect as the original (1990).

Ill watch part three , enjoyed the cartoon version of TMNT as well.

The only version I won't stand by is the Turtles In Time one that RT mentioned. Direct to TV bullshit with the wonkiest looking Turtles of all time.

I'll go Cowabunga on all your asses if this negativity keeps up.

Jun 6, 2018 19:28:21 GMT thereallt said:

Jun 6, 2018 17:25:52 GMT SM said:

I love the TMNT cartoon, but I feel all of the movies (originals & Bay ones) are bad.

The original was the only one that was any good.     The sequel was terrible and both Michael Bay movies are pure garbage.  

The original is the best of the bunch. In Secret of the Ooze they weren’t even allowed to use their weapons. 

Despite not getting a list in for this, I love that the original Ninja Turtles movie made the top three. The movie would have been high on my list, most likely top three for sure.

Jun 6, 2018 20:02:56 GMT SM said:

Jun 6, 2018 19:28:21 GMT thereallt said:

The original was the only one that was any good.     The sequel was terrible and both Michael Bay movies are pure garbage.  

The original is the best of the bunch. In Secret of the Ooze they weren’t even allowed to use their weapons. 

Yeah but they used combat coldcuts. Also they found a badass new crib that I wanted to live in.

1. Men in Black 

A person is smart. People are dumb, panicky dangerous animals and you know it. ~ Kay

Released 

1997

Credits 

Director: Barry Sonnenfeld 

Comic: Lowell Cunningham

Screenplay: Ed Soloman 

Cast 

Will Smith (Jay)

Tommy Lee Jones (Kay)

Linda Fiorentino (Laura)

Vincent D'Onofrio (Edgar)

Rip Torn (Zed)

Critical 

7.3/10 (IMDB)

92% (RT Critics)

79% (RT Audience)

Box Office 

Domestic Gross: $250,690,539 

Worldwide Gross: $589,390,539 

At the Oscars 

- Winner for Best Makeup 

- Nomination for Best Art Direction

- Nomination for Best Music , Original Song 

I love Men in Black , I think the turtles movies are the only ones to finish ahead of it.

Fun story with the first time watching it , I think I was in the 6th grade for class movie day and we had the option to pick the movie to watch , so we obviously went with an Adam Sandler flick to which our advisor said no because of the crude humor and language and instead forced MIB on us. So me and a few buddies in our ever defiant adolescent minds decided to count the swear words in this movie to try and make a point (there were something like 47 that we counted) - it really didn't prove anything except teachers suck.

In the end though I'm happy they did because I loved the movie then and I love it now. If you're a Will Smith fan there is really no way not to enjoy this movie because this puts his charisma and swagger on full display and does so with a perfect straight man to play off in Tommy Lee Jones.

The other highlight of the movie is D'Onofrio as Edgar , just an incredible job as the villian.

My list didn't have much in common with the final list.

1. Oldboy
2. Unbreakable
3. Scott Pilgrim vs The World
4. A History Of Violence
5. Kingsman: The Secret Service
6. Conan The Barbarian
7. Men In Black
8. Kick-Ass
9. Red Sonja
10. Road To Perdition

Oldboy is based on a manga. I never knew that until compiling this list. One of the best movies ever made.

I totally skipped over Men In Black when checking the “based on comics” lists. I totally would have voted for it. Ah well. Clearly everyone else did.

I’m glad I wasn’t the only person to vote for Oldboy. Surprised Constantine didn’t get more love. I thought it was great.

1. Watchmen
2. Kick-Ass
3. Scott Pilgrim vs. The World
4. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
5. Constantine
6. Oldboy
7. V for Vendetta
8. 300
9. Sin City
10. Hellboy

I'm not sure it MIB makes sense to me or is a WTF?! #1... Need to check my list, but don't think it made it on there.

Like RT, I don't think I had a lot of overlap this time.

Here is my list:

1. Mystery Men
2. Men in Black
3. The Incredibles
4. Unbreakable
5. Snowpiercer
6. Hellboy: The Golden Army
7. The Rocketeer
8. Dredd
9. Hellboy
10. A History of Violence

01 The Mask
02 Spawn
03 TMNT Original
04 Scott Pilgrim
05 Men in Black
06 Kick Ass
07 Akira
08 Barb Wire
09 Cowboys and Aliens
10 Watchmen

Jun 7, 2018 19:02:09 GMT SM said:

Here is my list:

1. Mystery Men
2. Men in Black
3. The Incredibles
4. Unbreakable
5. Snowpiercer
6. Hellboy: The Golden Army
7. The Rocketeer
8. Dredd
9. Hellboy
10. A History of Violence

I didn't see Snowpiercer until this weekend or else I totally would have put it on my list too. What a great movie.

Jun 7, 2018 16:57:52 GMT RT said:

I’m glad I wasn’t the only person to vote for Oldboy. Surprised Constantine didn’t get more love. I thought it was great.

1. Watchmen
2. Kick-Ass
3. Scott Pilgrim vs. The World
4. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
5. Constantine
6. Oldboy
7. V for Vendetta
8. 300
9. Sin City
10. Hellboy

Love Constantine, thought it was great... though it wouldn't have had made my list, as DC owns the character, same with The Watchmen.

10.V for Vendetta
9.The Rocketeer
8.Dredd 2012
7.Spawn
6.Sin City
5.The Crow
4.The Watchmen
3.Hellboy
2 Men in Black
1.300